eslHQ

eslHQ (http://www.eslhq.com/forums/)
-   English Questions (http://www.eslhq.com/forums/esl-forums/english-questions/)
-   -   She offered me (a) practical assistance (http://www.eslhq.com/forums/esl-forums/english-questions/she-offered-me-practical-assistance-56094/)

nelson13 Oct 13th, 2012 06:51 pm

She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
......

nelson13 Oct 13th, 2012 07:22 pm

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
......

susan53 Oct 14th, 2012 05:40 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
Always try and give contemporary examples. languages changes, and if your examples are more than 100 years old, the reason for the difference is just the changes in the language over time. It would make no sense to say eg Shakespeare uses "thou". Why can't I say it now? Find contemporary examples of the language point you want to ask about, otherwise you may just be wasting your time asking the question.

However, here that's not the problem. I think you need to look at the concepts being expressed.

There is no such thing as a countable or uncountable noun. Nouns may be used countably or uncountably, and many can be used both ways. So you are quite right when you say that the concept of "countability" is used to express "a type of". Some examples:

Gorgonzola and Cheddar are my favourite cheeses.
Pinot Grigio is a popular wine from the Veneto region.
She spoke with a sincerity that was moving.


In both these sentences, and your examples of bonhomie, reverence and pulchritude, you could add "type of" before the noun or noun phrase:

Gorgonzola and Cheddar are my favourite type of cheeses.
Pinot Grigio is a popular type of wine from the Veneto region.
She spoke with a type of sincerity that was moving.
There was a type of casual bonhomie between the actors at rehearsals.
I endow her with a type of pulchritude that the women I have seen do not have.
... a type of deep reverence for the poet.


Notice though, that all these examples either refer to concrete objects (cheese, wine, etc) or personal qualities or feelings (sincerity, bonhomie, pulcheritude). Assistance is neither of these, so you need at least to hypothesise that it's the semantic concept that makes the difference
Assistance is the nominalisation of a verb and refers to an action. Nominalisations are sometimes used countably, and sometimes uncountably, and many so-called uncountable nominalisations are used countably in the type of sentence you are asking about. Eg : He has an impressive knowledge of his subject.

but there are a few which only seem to be used uncountably - so if you wanted to add a determiner, it would be some :

She offered me some practical assistance...
We did some careful research into the problem.


That, I'm afraid, is as close as I can get.

nelson13 Oct 16th, 2012 04:51 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
......

susan53 Oct 16th, 2012 05:22 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
Yes, but it's a translation of a work written in 1875, and obviously the translation will reflect the language of that time, not modern English. No contemporary writer would use the expression "endow her with a pulchritude". The style is archaic.

nelson13 Oct 16th, 2012 05:40 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
......

susan53 Oct 16th, 2012 06:05 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
Sorry but I don't see the parallel. The two sentences are quite different in style. The Summer extract is elaborate and poetic, but contemporary English. The Faustino translation is consciously attempting to reproduce 19th century style.

And as you say - regret is an excellent example of what I said before : most abstract nouns can be used countably or uncountably.

susan53 Oct 16th, 2012 06:05 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
Sorry but I don't see the parallel. The two sentences are quite different in style. The Summer extract is elaborate and poetic, but contemporary English. The Faustino translation is consciously attempting to reproduce 19th century style.

And as you say - regret is an excellent example of what I said before : most abstract nouns can be used countably or uncountably.

nelson13 Oct 16th, 2012 07:33 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
.....

susan53 Oct 16th, 2012 07:54 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
I've always used the Grammar of Contemporary English (Longman). my students tell me they like the Cambridge English Grammar.

nelson13 Oct 16th, 2012 09:07 am

Re: She offered me (a) practical assistance
 
......


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:54 am.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2