View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Unread Nov 24th, 2010, 06:17 am
susan53 susan53 is offline
Sue
 
Join Date: Oct 8th, 2006
Location: Milan
Posts: 1,406
susan53 is on a distinguished road
Default Re: Future vs Future progressive

I'm presuming that by this you mean will + simple infinitive and will + progressive infinitive.

You need to look first of all at the meaning of will - which may be prediction or volition but is not necessarily future : this post explains it.

With these infinitives the action may be either present or future - but that's determined by the context and, if signalled linguistically at all, it's done by a time adverbial (at the moment / tomorrow etc). "Will" itself is always present - it has the meaning I predict or I intend to - in other words it expresses present prediction/volition regarding another event which may be present, future or (with the perfect infinitive) past.

Then think about the simple and progressive infinitives : the simple infinitive expresses an action as "complete" while the progressive infinitive sees it as ongoing.

So : you have four possible combinations

Prediction + on-going event :
John's on holiday at the moment, lucky thing. He'll be lying on the beach at the moment while we're stuck here at work. (present = I predict he is lying...)
At this time tomorrow, we'll be flying home.



Prediction + "complete" event :
(Knock on the door) Oh, that will be John. (present = I predict that is John)
I expect we'll arrive about 7.

Volition + on-going event :
Right, I'll be going then. (= I intend to go now)
This one is, I think relatively rare in comparison with the others, and is always an alternative to the simple (Right then, I'll go now) but that's just a hunch which may be wrong. Can anyone think of an example where the progressive would be essential? I also can't think of any examples where it would be used to express volition regarding a future event. I usually present it as an option, used when the speaker really wants to stress the "on-goingness" of the action.

Volition + "complete" event : Is everyone here? OK, I'll start now. (= I intend to start now)
I'll call you when David arrives.
__________________
An ELT Notebook
The DELTA Course
Reply With Quote